zenbelly

recipes for real life, safer skincare, clean crafted wine

Best Ever Paleo Stuffing (Dressing)

by 61 Comments

Your brain called. It said it's tired of thinking about what to cook.

Enter your email here and get weekly meal plans delivered straight to your inbox. 

Plus, instantly download my Instant Pot ebook when you sign up.

Thanks! Keep an eye on your inbox for updates.

My uncle Allan makes the best stuffing. Hands down. The best. I was a bit shocked the first time I attended a Thanksgiving hosted by someone other than my Aunt and Uncle. Their stuffing was different. What the heck. Thank goodness I’ve created a paleo stuffing that is reminiscent of his. paleo stuffing

the best ever paleo stuffing might just be the best stuffing ever, period.

Everyone’s got that one Thanksgiving dish, right? The one that has to be on the table. If missing, you get all pouty and you might even sulk, because whoever spent the past four days cooking neglected to take the time to make the dish that you look forward to all year.

The nerve.

For me, it’s stuffing. I don’t even really care what animal is at the center of the table. I’ve never gotten all that excited about squash or sweet potatoes. Mashed potatoes are always delicious, but it would be a gross exaggeration to say that I get excited about them.

There are, apparently, a gazillion different takes on stuffing (or dressing, if it’s not actually stuffed inside the bird. I still call it stuffing. I don’t care what Martha says. Dressing goes on salad.) There’s the sourdough variety, I’m sure a popular choice here in my beloved San Francisco.

I did for a moment ponder the idea of making a version with a loaf from Bread SRSLY– the best gluten-free sourdough in all the land. (Update: I later did just that, and you can find that recipe HERE) I also considered making Allan’s recipe with gluten-free cornbread. That’s what I did last year, and it was incredible.
paleo stuffing
But then I got a message from my friend Johnny, asking for some Paleo Thanksgiving pointers. He was comparing Paleo stuffing recipes, none of which looked like the one I love, and can’t have Thanksgiving without. It felt like a challenge I had to accept.

Add subtitle text (1)

In true compulsive recipe developer fashion, I was in the car in about 15 seconds, list in hand. I could already smell Thanksgiving.

Print

Best Ever Paleo Stuffing (Dressing)

  • Author: zenbelly
  • Prep Time: 30 minutes
  • Cook Time: 75 minutes
  • Total Time: 1 hour 45 minutes
  • Yield: 8-10 servings 1x
  • Category: Thanksgiving
  • Method: saute, bake
  • Cuisine: American
Print

Description

It’s sweet, it’s savory, it’s technically a side dish but could easily be the main course.

Scale

Ingredients

1 pound ground pork
2 cups diced onions
2 cups diced bell peppers
4 cups (about 1 pound) diced mushrooms
2 cups diced apples
8 oz fresh cranberries
1 cup toasted chopped pecans (optional)
~ 2 T duck fat, bacon fat, butter, or coconut oil. (I used duck fat)
1 T fresh rosemary, minced
1 T fresh thyme, minced
2–3 leaves fresh sage (or 1/2 t dried)
sea salt
4 eggs
1/4 cup chicken or turkey stock
2 T coconut flour

Instructions

  1. Prepare all of your ingredients and preheat your oven to 350°F.
  2. Melt about 2 teaspoons of your fat of choice in a large cast iron or stainless skillet over medium-high heat.
  3. Add the pork and cook until it just browns, 3-4 minutes. Add a pinch of salt and remove with a slotted spoon and place in a large bowl. Pour off excess liquid from your skillet and add another teaspoon of fat.
  4. Turn the heat down to medium and add the onions. Sauté until golden brown and soft, 6-8 minutes. Add to the bowl with the pork.
  5. Add another teaspoon of fat, and sauté bell peppers for 4 minutes, stirring often. Add to the bowl with the other ingredients.
  6. Throw in yet another teaspoon of fat, turn the heat up to medium-high, and add the mushrooms. Sauté for about 3 minutes, stirring often. Add to the bowl with the other ingredients.
  7. To the large bowl, add the apples, pecans, cranberries, herbs, and a good pinch of salt.
  8. In a medium bowl, beat together the eggs, chicken or turkey stock, and coconut flour. Add a pinch of salt if you’re stock isn’t salted.
  9. Pour the liquid into the large bowl and mix.
  10. Pour the whole thing into an oven safe casserole and bake for one hour.
  11. Allow to cool for 10 minutes before eating. It will firm up a bit.

Notes

Why on earth am I making you sauté all of the vegetables separately? Two reasons: 

  1. It’s a lot of stuff, you probably don’t have a pan that fits it all.
  2. If you cook it all at the same time, you’ll wind up steaming, not sautéing.

Keywords: Thanksgiving, stuffing, dressing, paleo


All of the links on zenbelly.com are for information purposes, however some are affiliate links to books, products or services. Any sponsored posts are clearly labelled as being sponsored content. Some ads on this site are served by ad networks and the advertised products are not necessarily recommended by Zenbelly.

Comments

  1. Wow, that looks amazing! Wish my husband liked stuffing like this…he’s a “classic” guy (bread, onions, celery, herbs). But I might have to make this for me!

    Reply

    • There is so much flavor from the other ingredients, I’m not sure… It won’t be bad by any means, but I’m guessing that sausage would lend itself better to a simpler recipe. Let me know how it turns out if you try it!

      Reply

    • I cooked it in a pan that’s about 12″x8″. As part of a Thanksgiving spread, where everyone takes small amounts of everything, I’d say you could about get 8-10 servings out of this. If I make it again soon (which I plan to) I will give you a more accurate answer!

      Reply

    • I think so. The reason I didn’t put it in the make ahead and freeze section on my Thanksgivukkah guide is because I haven’t tried it. So I’m not 100% sure what freezing it will do to the texture of the veggies in it. But if I were to guess, I’d say it should be fine!

      Reply

    • You could do that… I find that ground meat tends to render somewhat watery fat, so not as good for browning the ingredients you put in next. But not a bad thing, either!

      Reply

  8. I did a trial run of this recipe tonight and the flavor is fantastic … I am wondering if the finished product is as you intended… I can’t tell from your photo but my egg mixture ended up at the bottom of the casserole dish and cooked like a souffle of sorts at the bottom…so when I servie it, it definitely has egg components throughout…is that as you intended?

    Reply

    • The egg acts more as a binder, than something that is apparent in the end result (when I made it, anyway) Did you mix it with the coconut flour before stirring it into the meat mixture?

      Reply

      • Yes, I did mix it as instructed … and now it’s totally perfect. I thought maybe I used too big of a casserole dish (13 x9) but now I don’t think it matters. It was just my initial freak-out straight out of the oven/straight into the dish. Mixing it a bit, it all incorporated well and it truly is a keeper, delicious, & addictive. Thank you!

  9. I’m wondering about turning this into a main dish by adding an additional pound of ground pork. Other than needing to adjust the seasonings, would there anything else to worry about?

    Reply

  11. The heck with Thanksgiving, this will be a yummy breakfast to just have on hand, made in individual containers to heat up and go! Thanks! can’t wait to try it!

    Reply

  12. My family would revolt if we didn’t have our southern cornbread ‘dressing’. So instead I am going to make this for thanksgiving breakfast along side some eggs. Yum!

    Reply

  13. Any possible substitutes for the mushrooms? The recipe sounds good, but the ‘shrooms, I can’t stomach and it happens to be a major ingredient, so can’t really omit them. Maybe zucchini?

    Reply

    • I’d just omit them! They’re there to add a mushroom flavor, but there is enough other stuff in the recipe that it will still taste great. Once they’re cooked down, they don’t really add much bulk to the overall dish.

      Reply

    • I need to substitute out the mushrooms, too. I like the flavor but not the texture of mushrooms. I was thinking of adding small cubes of yellow squash? Also, I read somewhere there is mushroom in a powder format that might be good to sprinkle in if you are okay with the flavor.

      Thanks for sharing your recipe. I love trying new things.

      Reply

      • You could definitely add squash. this stuffing has so many flavors that there’s plenty of room for improvisation! Mushroom powder would be a great addition for extra umami! Thanks, Joan 🙂

  14. I made this for Thanksgiving yesterday, with a few tweaks to make it more like my mom’s stuffing, and it was fabulous! My major subs were celery for green pepper, pork breakfast sausage instead of ground pork and only used fresh sage, no other herbs. I also added chestnuts. Sooo good! I didn’t even miss my bread stuffing. Thank you!

    Reply

    • Any are really fine! I like using a firmer variety, so they hold together when cooked. Pink lady, Grannny Smith, Honeycrisp… Or whatever variety is on sale, since this stuffing requires quite the ingredient list! 🙂

      Reply

  16. Found this on my hunt for paleo thanksgiving side dishes and it looks fantastic…wondering if you think adding butternut squash is possible? Thank you

    Reply

    • Definitely! If you cube it really small it should cook evenly with everything else. Let me know how it turns out if you try it 🙂

      Reply

  17. Do you think this could be prepared ahead of time, up to the point of putting it into the oven and then baking it when it’s time? I am doing all of my cooking a day or two before Thanksgiving, because we host it here and it starts at noon, so there just isn’t time to cook everything that morning AND look presentable. So I was thinking of doing everything ahead of time and keeping it in the fridge until that morning. I don’t want to cook it completely ahead, I still want it to be fresh out of the oven. Maybe wait to add the egg/flour mixture until time to bake or do you think it would be fine if I added it all?

    Reply

    • Yes you can definitely prepare it ahead of time and cook it the day of! You can add the egg + flour ahead of time, too. Have a great Thanksgiving!

      Reply

    • Sure. The eggs are just to hold it all together a bit, along with the coconut flour. It’s just for texture purposes, so it will still be delish if you leave them out! I’m not sure how flax would work, if it binds with coconut flour when baked the way eggs do?

      Reply

  19. Added the butternut and it was delicious! I microwaved it about 5 minutes before tossing in the the bell peppers to make sure it would cook enough. Thank you for this recipe!

    Reply

  20. This was my first time making a Paleo Thanksgiving and I am totally beholden to you for your delicious, creative recipes. The “Best Ever Paleo Stuffing” was really aptly named. Before Paleo I used to think I made a pretty decent stuffing and was skeptical about making one gluten-free. Yours made converts not only of me but my guests too! Your schedule was a life-saver: I followed it faithfully and for once, didn’t stress over things being cooked and on the table simultaneously. Thanks to you it just came together. Thank you for a Thanksgiving I was able to enjoy!

    Reply

  21. hi, you mentioned a schedule in a previous comment. I don’t see it, could you point me in right direction pls? I’d also like to make as much as possible ahead of time. Thanks!

    Reply

    • Hi Kathryn! I think the schedule that’s referred to is the one I did last year, when Hanukkah and Thanksgiving were in the same week… It’s in two columns though if you’re just looking to follow the Thanksgiving part! It’s here:

      Reply

  24. Hi, our family is looking forward to this dressing! Mouth-watering. One of us cannot eat coconut, however, as well as anything nuts. Bummer! What else could be substituted for the 2 T coconut flour? Think of making the whole thing, or maybe a little extra, then scooping out a little bit for my mom-in-law, baking that separately, with a little egg & rice flour in her dish. Anyway — thanks for your amazing dishes. We love EVERY SINGLE recipe of yours. (My spouse is a longtime co-owner of Other Avenues, even!)

    Reply

    • Thanks so much! For the flour, I would just add a different flour, it’s just to hold it together a little bit. You could use rice or arrowroot or any other starch that you can all eat! Coconut flour is more absorbent than other flours, so I’d use more of whatever you use, around 1/4 cup. That’s so cool about OA! Have a great Thanksgiving!

      Reply

  25. I was impressed by how much this recipe yielded. It’s so nice to have a lower carb dish with all the amazing flavors of a good stuffing. I did sub celery for the bell pepper. For me, it needed extra salt and maybe I would increase the sage and rosemary next time. This is a real keeper that I’m grateful to have, thank you!!

    Reply

  26. Do you have a recipe for corn bread? I seem to be failing. I would ideally want something I can use for a sandwich. I thought maybe cassava flour would help, so I came here first.

    Reply

    • I don’t have one published, but have made it using a regular recipe and cassava flour. I can’t remember the exact ratio I used but tend to go light on cassava compared to AP flour since it is so absorbent. So if a recipe calls for 1 cup of flour, I’d use half cup of cassava and maybe 2-4 tablespoons of tapioca or arrowroot. Sorry that’s not anywhere near exact but hopefully gets you going in the right direction!

      Reply

  27. I am traveling but want to take this so if I made ahead then reheated in slow cooker since oven space limited, what do you think?
    Also cooking sweet potato and apple dish that calls for 1/4 cup bourbon but want dish to be alcohol free, what would you replace with?
    Thanks so much. Can’t wait to try the stuffing.

    Reply

  28. Simone,
    Do you think I could turn this into AIP by using something other than green peppers and using gelatin for an egg substitute and just eliminating the other stuff not on AIP. It sounds too yummy to have to wait till next Thanksgiving to try!

    Reply

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆ ★☆

Privacy Policy